Skip to content
Spend $24.99 more and get free shipping!
Country/region
Country/region
  • New
  • Nose
    • Opal Nose Rings
    • Double Spiral Nose Rings
    • 14kt Gold & Platinum
    • Nose Hoops
    • Under $3 Nose Rings
    • Septum Rings & Clickers
    • Gem Crystal Nose Rings
    • Nose Retainers
    • Diamond & Precious Gem Nose Rings
    • Ear to Nose Ring Chains
    • Themed Nose Rings (Sports, Symbols, etc.)
    • Micro Nose Rings
  • Belly
    • Belly Ring Monthly Club
    • Animal Belly Rings
    • Holiday Belly Rings
    • Picture & Word Belly Rings
    • Top Mount Belly Rings
    • Handcrafted Belly RIngs
    • Badass Belly Rings
    • Custom & Personalized Belly Rings
    • Just Girly Things Belly Rings
    • Pregnancy Belly Rings
    • Tropical Belly Rings
    • 14kt Gold Belly Rings
    • Belly Chains
    • Glow & Mood Belly Rings
    • Naughty Belly Rings
    • Rose Gold Belly Rings
    • Under $3 Belly Rings
  • 14k Gold
  • $1.99
    • $1.99 Belly Button Rings
    • $1.99 Nose Rings
    • $1.99 Industrial Barbells
    • $1.99 Nipple Rings
    • $1.99 Cartlilage Rings
    • $1.99 Circular Barbells & Captive Bead Rings
    • $1.99 Lip Rings
    • $1.99 Plugs & Tunnels
    • $1.99 Tongue Rings
    • $1.99 Eyebrow Rings
    • $1.99 Faux Piercing
    • Halloween Clearance
    • Belly Rings
    • Cheater Plugs
    • Faux Body Jewelry
    • Nipple Rings
    • Replacement Parts
  • Ear
    • Hypoallergenic Flat Back Earrings
    • Industrial Piercing Monthly Club
    • Cartilage Hoops
    • Earrings
    • Helix Piercing Jewelry
    • Rook Piercing Jewelry
    • Ear Curations
    • Conch Piercing Jewelry
    • Ear Hangers
    • Industrial Ear Piercing Jewelry
    • Tragus Piercing Jewelry
    • Cartilage Studs
    • Daith Piercing Jewelry
    • Ear Weights
    • Plugs, Tapers & Tunnels
    • Christmas Earrings
  • Nipple Rings
    • Nipple Ring Monthly Club
    • Captive Nipple Rings
    • Heart & Flower Nipple Rings
    • Nipple Chains
    • Under $5 Nipple Rings
    • Handcrafted Nipple Rings
    • Dangling Nipple Rings
    • Holiday Nipple Rings
    • Nipple Shields
    • Faux Nipple Rings
    • Animal-theme Nipple Rings
    • Glow in the Dark Nipple Rings
    • Nipple Barbells
    • Sun & Star Nipple Rings
    • Threadless
  • More
  • Membership
BodyCandy
Popular Searches:nose rings,belly rings,labret,tongue rings,tragus
0
  • New
    • Opal Nose Rings
    • Double Spiral Nose Rings
    • 14kt Gold & Platinum
    • Nose Hoops
    • Under $3 Nose Rings
    • Septum Rings & Clickers
    • Gem Crystal Nose Rings
    • Nose Retainers
    • Diamond & Precious Gem Nose Rings
    • Ear to Nose Ring Chains
    • Themed Nose Rings (Sports, Symbols, etc.)
    • Micro Nose Rings
    • Belly Ring Monthly Club
    • Animal Belly Rings
    • Holiday Belly Rings
    • Picture & Word Belly Rings
    • Top Mount Belly Rings
    • Handcrafted Belly RIngs
    • Badass Belly Rings
    • Custom & Personalized Belly Rings
    • Just Girly Things Belly Rings
    • Pregnancy Belly Rings
    • Tropical Belly Rings
    • 14kt Gold Belly Rings
    • Belly Chains
    • Glow & Mood Belly Rings
    • Naughty Belly Rings
    • Rose Gold Belly Rings
    • Under $3 Belly Rings
  • 14k Gold
    • $1.99 Belly Button Rings
    • $1.99 Nose Rings
    • $1.99 Industrial Barbells
    • $1.99 Nipple Rings
    • $1.99 Cartlilage Rings
    • $1.99 Circular Barbells & Captive Bead Rings
    • $1.99 Lip Rings
    • $1.99 Plugs & Tunnels
    • $1.99 Tongue Rings
    • $1.99 Eyebrow Rings
    • $1.99 Faux Piercing
    • Halloween Clearance
    • Belly Rings
    • Cheater Plugs
    • Faux Body Jewelry
    • Nipple Rings
    • Replacement Parts
    • Hypoallergenic Flat Back Earrings
    • Industrial Piercing Monthly Club
    • Cartilage Hoops
    • Earrings
    • Helix Piercing Jewelry
    • Rook Piercing Jewelry
    • Ear Curations
    • Conch Piercing Jewelry
    • Ear Hangers
    • Industrial Ear Piercing Jewelry
    • Tragus Piercing Jewelry
    • Cartilage Studs
    • Daith Piercing Jewelry
    • Ear Weights
    • Plugs, Tapers & Tunnels
    • Christmas Earrings
    • Nipple Ring Monthly Club
    • Captive Nipple Rings
    • Heart & Flower Nipple Rings
    • Nipple Chains
    • Under $5 Nipple Rings
    • Handcrafted Nipple Rings
    • Dangling Nipple Rings
    • Holiday Nipple Rings
    • Nipple Shields
    • Faux Nipple Rings
    • Animal-theme Nipple Rings
    • Glow in the Dark Nipple Rings
    • Nipple Barbells
    • Sun & Star Nipple Rings
    • Threadless
  • More
  • Membership
Account
  • Nose
  • Nipple
  • Belly
  • $1.99
  • Tees
  • New
  • Best Sellers
  • Ear
  • 14K Gold
  • More
nose rings
Nose
belly button rings
Belly
nipple rings
Nipple
septum rings
Septum
earrings
Earrings
tragus jewelry
Tragus
tongue rings
Tongue
industrial piercing
Industrial
plugs piercing
Plugs
lip ring piercing
Lip
conch piercing jewelry
Conch
helix piercing
Helix
rook piercing
Rook
daith piercing
Daith
14k gold piercing jewelry
14k GOLD
piercing tattoo aftercare
Aftercare
Personalized

Cookie policy

I agree to the processing of my data in accordance with the conditions set out in the policy of Privacy.

Cart

Your cart is empty

Start shopping

Results for "captive replacement"

Filters

Filters

$
to
$
197 products
Sort by
Sort by
14G 9/16 Blue Gem Blue Mermaid Tail Stars Nipple Shield Set
14G 9/16 Blue Gem Blue Mermaid Tail Stars Nipple Shield Set
Sale price$19.99 Regular price$38.99
Sold out
16G 7/16 White Flexible Bioplast Square Septum Retainer
16G 7/16 White Flexible Bioplast Square Septum Retainer
Sale price$3.99 Regular price$23.99
Sold out
Red CZ Gem Black Passion Heart Skull Double Mount Belly Ring Red CZ Gem Black Passion Heart Skull Double Mount Belly Ring
Red CZ Gem Black Passion Heart Skull Double Mount Belly Ring
Sale price$15.99 Regular price$44.99
Sold out
Red Gem Black Gothic Bat Heart Belly Ring Red Gem Black Gothic Bat Heart Belly Ring
Red Gem Black Gothic Bat Heart Belly Ring
Sale price$15.99 Regular price$34.99
Sold out
16G 7/16 Pink Flexible Bioplast Square Septum Retainer
16G 7/16 Pink Flexible Bioplast Square Septum Retainer
Sale price$3.99 Regular price$23.99
Sold out
1/2 Aqua Gem Iridescent Blue Mermaid Scale Screw Fit Plug Set 1/2 Aqua Gem Iridescent Blue Mermaid Scale Screw Fit Plug Set
1/2 Aqua Gem Iridescent Blue Mermaid Scale Screw Fit Plug Set
Sale price$10.99 Regular price$37.99
Sold out
Aqua Gem Iridescent Blue Mermaid Scale Screw Fit Plug Set 6mm to 22mm Aqua Gem Iridescent Blue Mermaid Scale Screw Fit Plug Set 6mm to 22mm
Aqua Gem Iridescent Blue Mermaid Scale Screw Fit Plug Set 6mm to 22mm
Sale priceFrom $1.99 Regular price$38.99
Sold out
14G 9/16 316L Steel Skulls Clear Gem with Titanium Barbell Nipple Rings
14G 9/16 316L Steel Skulls Clear Gem with Titanium Barbell Nipple Rings
Sale price$20.99 Regular price$43.99
Sold out
Purple Blue Gem Faceted Valentines Day Heart Belly Ring Purple Blue Gem Faceted Valentines Day Heart Belly Ring
Purple Blue Gem Faceted Valentines Day Heart Belly Ring
Sale price$9.99 Regular price$28.99
Sold out
14G 1/2 Black Faerie Wings Fantasy Barbell Nipple Ring Set 14G 1/2 Black Faerie Wings Fantasy Barbell Nipple Ring Set
14G 1/2 Black Faerie Wings Fantasy Barbell Nipple Ring Set
Sale price$25.99 Regular price$44.99
Sold out
16G 7/16 Red Flexible Bioplast Square Septum Retainer
16G 7/16 Red Flexible Bioplast Square Septum Retainer
Sale price$3.99 Regular price$23.99
Sold out
20 Gauge Red CZ Gem Gold Tone Heart Queen L Shape Nose Ring 7mm Red CZ Heart Queen L Shape Nose Ring Gold Tone 20 Gauge
20G 7mm Red CZ Gem Gold Tone Heart Queen L Shape Nose Ring
Sale price$15.99 Regular price$35.99
Sold out
Iridescent Gem Black Captivating Colors Belly Ring Set of 5 Iridescent Gem Black Captivating Colors Belly Ring Set of 5
Iridescent Gem Black Captivating Colors Belly Ring Set of 5
Sale price$20.99 Regular price$39.99
Sold out
Clear Gem Gold Tone Fly Away Butterfly Dangle Belly Ring Clear Gem Gold Tone Fly Away Butterfly Dangle Belly Ring
Clear Gem Gold Tone Fly Away Butterfly Dangle Belly Ring
Sale price$12.99 Regular price$34.99
Sold out
Pink Faux Opal Captive Heart Dangle Belly Ring
Pink Faux Opal Captive Heart Dangle Belly Ring
Sale price$2.98 Regular price$30.99
Sold out
Clear Gem Winter Fun Snowflake Double Mount Belly Ring Clear Gem Winter Fun Snowflake Double Mount Belly Ring
Clear Gem Winter Fun Snowflake Double Mount Belly Ring
Sale price$12.99 Regular price$31.99
Sold out
14G 7/16 Green Flexible Bioplast Square Septum Retainer
14G 7/16 Green Flexible Bioplast Square Septum Retainer
Sale price$3.99 Regular price$23.99
Sold out
Clear CZ Love Ribbon Heart Belly Ring Love Ribbon Heart Double Mount Belly Ring Love Ribbon Heart Double Mount Belly Ring CZ Gem Heart Double Mount Belly Ring
Love Ribbon Heart Double Mount Belly Ring
Sale priceFrom $15.99 Regular price$35.99
Sold out
16G 1/4 Black Cat Mouse Halloween Cartilage Tragus Earring 16G 1/4 Black Cat Mouse Halloween Cartilage Tragus Earring
16G 1/4 Black Cat Mouse Halloween Cartilage Tragus Earring
Sale price$9.99 Regular price$28.99
Sold out
16G 7/16 Purple Flexible Bioplast Square Septum Retainer
16G 7/16 Purple Flexible Bioplast Square Septum Retainer
Sale price$3.99 Regular price$23.99
Sold out
16G 5/16 Purple Tourmaline Black Majestic Dragon Labret Tragus
16G 5/16 Purple Tourmaline Black Majestic Dragon Labret Tragus
Sale price$12.99 Regular price$31.99
Sold out
Iridescent Gem Rose Gold Tone Captivating Colors Belly Ring Set of 5 Iridescent Gem Rose Gold Tone Captivating Colors Belly Ring Set of 5
Iridescent Gem Rose Gold Tone Captivating Colors Belly Ring Set of 5
Sale price$20.99 Regular price$39.99
Sold out
7/8 Black Spinning Bullet Chamber Plug 7/8 Black Spinning Bullet Chamber Plug
7/8 Black Spinning Bullet Chamber Plug
Sale price$7.99 Regular price$36.99
Sold out
Aurora Gem Blue Orb Nautical Vibe Double Flare Plug Set 6mm to 25mm Aurora Gem Blue Orb Nautical Vibe Double Flare Plug Set 6mm to 25mm
Aurora Gem Blue Orb Nautical Vibe Double Flare Plug Set 6mm to 25mm
Sale priceFrom $1.99 Regular price$39.99
Sold out
1…56789

Want Your Order Faster?

Add VIP ordering processing and...

  • You Jump To The Front Of The Line
  • Your Order Ships Before Everyone Else!

About

  • Contact
  • About
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Piercing Q&A

Customers

  • Wishlist
  • Monthly Club
  • Membership
  • Rewards
  • Size Guide
  • Care Guide
  • Shipping Policy
  • Return Policy

Need Help?

Customer Service

Monday through Friday from 9am to 5pm EST

+1 800-694-1426

Subscribe

Sign up for emails and never miss a drop!

MyBodyJewelry.com

© 2026 BodyCandy. All Rights Reserved.   | Policies: Terms of Service Privacy Policy Messaging Privacy Policy Messaging Terms & Conditions Accessibility